Porch Pirates Mystery Boxes Reviews 

Unfortunately much worse than I anticipated. Ordered a skincare and beauty box with clearly used items. Also ordered a traditional mystery box with blue tape and received several empty bags and opened items. The smell of some was strong and unpleasant. Literally a box of amazon returns that people did not want due to poor quality. Very expensive for terrible items.

I paid over $30 for the Scallywag Mystery Box after seeing the Switch 2 promotion. What I received: a 1:24 scale Ford Bronco with a wheel snapped off, a pack of painting pads for a tool I don't own, an HDMI cable, a package of men's Medium underwear, and soap dispenser heads with no bottles. No bottles. Just the heads.

The Bronco arrived damaged. I repaired it with super glue. The whole box would retail for maybe $15 to $20 if you bought this stuff on Temu, which is almost certainly where it came from.

The "1 in 72 boxes contains a Nintendo Switch 2" framing exists to make you feel like you're playing a game with real odds. You are not. You are paying premium prices for warehouse liquidation and shelf-pull junk dressed up as a fun experience. The randomness is the product. The contents are an afterthought.

I won't be ordering again and I'd strongly encourage anyone reading this to think carefully before handing over $50 for a box of items someone else didn't want.

Easy ordering, prompt delivery, well packaged, and useful items. I will definitely order again.

This was my 1st mystery box ever. Totally enjoyed it. My sister was with me at the unboxing and then she ordered her own!

Took a bit to get it shipped but overall it was great. Mostly smaller stuff that can be bundled but works for what I need! Will order again

I love mystery boxes and this was a fun one. I will probably get another but will likely get a bigger box so I can get the pirate hat and eye patch. Arghhh!!

Shipping was lightning-fast - my silver tape apple chance mystery box arrived 2 days ahead of schedule. No apple item this time, but i received a full face snorkel mask and a travel backpack - plus over a dozen other useful items. I'm so glad I ordered this as a subscription! Thank you Porch Pirates!

It was a great first experience.. I was looking forward to seeing a LV bag 🤗 but knew my chances were slim. The box was soaked from sitting in the rain all day but it was good.

I liked the many little surprises that I received.Some products were not for me but I donated them. Everything was useful and I felt my money was well spent.

Got 2 boxes and will be getting more. I was so impressed with the amount of items I got as well as the fact they are things that are sellable not junk. My first box was 69.99 and I got $ 286 worth of merchandise the second one was 59.99 and I got $ 383 worth of merchandise. Will do this again. Had a mishap with my address was able to get a hold of someone and they fixed it immediately sending it out to me right away. Thank you for your exceptional service.

It is always fun doing mystery boxes and it adds to the excitement having the chance to win a big item prize! I think it's awesome porch pirates adds this extra mystery to an already fun experience!

The boxes were interesting. A little surprised that some of the clothing items were dingy looking. All in all they were okay.

Good variety of things just not enough resell value.

Good service

I love that I won a Michael Kors purse but I received some really nice other things too. The lady I talked to on the phone was super nice and I like the idea of supporting small businesses.

I had alot of toilet cleaning items in the boxes. I ordered 4 and all of them had almost the same items.

Many counterfeit goods, many items without barcodes, many items with fake barcodes, many items with fake QR codes.. don't recommend.. if you buy these boxes from them directly or from Liquidation places expect at least half to be low quality or counterfeit

The boxes were shipped and delivered quickly and the items were overall mostly useful- some duplicates amongst the two boxes but overall satisfied.

Katie was incredible with customer service! Not only that, I was amazed at how quickly she got back to me!!! I’ve placed an order and if I don’t win, I don’t even care! I am supporting this small business and backing it 100000%. You guys are incredible!!

Just received my first box and I’m pretty happy with it overall. There was a nice variety of items inside, and everything felt well put together. Definitely a good first impression.