Mystery Tackle Box Reviews 

I have been signed up a few months now have gotten pretty solid stuff every single month box’s always show up on the 10th never have been a day later. Had a payment issue a while back and they sent me a free lure plus my box to fix the situation. I also was somehow signed up for Karl’s and I completely forgot to cancel after the free trial and was greatly refunded immediately without any hesitation 10/10 service with mtb!

It's great products I get one every month and also buy extra boxes love love MTB

Updated 5/23: Eventually, Catchco got back with us and they were able to "make it right” by letting us pick out the rod we had won - they also threw in a reel as well. Thanks guys! Much appreciated. Increasing to 5 stars from 1 for that! 👍🏻

Original Review Feb/23: We Won!!! At least we thought.
My 14 y/o son saved up to buy a Motherlode Mysterybox from Catchco and we were excited - we love the tackle that we get, but also the chance to win a prize. We entered our code and saw that we had WON a Googan rod! Called the number on the back… no answer and you can’t leave a message. Tried the email on the card and no responses. Eventually, after direct messaging someone on social media they told us to read the fine print which said the contest was over at the beginning of Jan `23. DISAPPOINTED for sure - especially when you plug a code at mtbmotherlode.com and it tells you you won a Googan rod. If there is an expiration date on the codes and prizes available… Shouldn’t there be an expiration date on the outside of the boxes?!? Customers shouldn’t have the lure of winning something beyond the tackle they purchase, only to receive an empty hook in the mouth. Ugh. Catchco, can you help with this?

I think this is one of the best things for experienced and non-experience fishers to have each item you get they tell you what it’s used for and how to use it! Absolutely an amazing product from you guys. Absolutely love it.

I just love this product, I tell all my fishing buddys to sign up and get themselves a monthly gift!

Great economical way to add to your tackle box!

Love the products great sense of Florida fishing colors

I received a 3 month subscription as a Christmas gift and I was pleasantly surprised at the quality of tackle I received. I chose the type of fishing I do and 90% of what came in the box was useful to me.

It's like Christmas every month! I live on a canal in SW Florida and it has been fun to take what comes out on my kayak in my free time. My January box netted 6 sea trout the largest was 20 in and 4 came on top water. It was a BLAST!!

Really good great place to lures that you never buy in the store

They always send you good stuff . The customer service is of the charts. They will always make things right. Will highly recommend.

Quality tackle can't wait to get my new box every month

My 15 year old son loves fishing and this was the perfect gift for him! It was super easy to order, and was laid out in an easy manner to understand online. My son is loving everything he gets and he can't wait to see what comes every month! Highly suggest this product and company!!

I bought a mystery box from a retail store as a gift for my husband
We found that there were 2 items missing
Karl's answered my message promptly and sent replacements.
Thanks, guys, we'll be doing business with you again.
It's always nice to deal with companies who put customers first

I was missing day 8 and day 5 of the 12 days of Fishmas purchased from Walmart. The pangish jighead and dynamic lures micro spinnerbaits were missing and the package had not been damaged and the wrap was still over the box

I just bought my little sister a small tackle box and a mini mystery box for ten bucks at my local Walmart. Mini box #1. I was hoping she’d maybe get a hard bait and a bag of plastics but no… 2 bags of different brands of “craws” and and a bag of worms. No hooks no weights. I understand it’s ten bucks, but I bought it to get her into fishing. I mean the box has pictures of hard baits right on it. Surely wasn’t expecting what seems like old inventory.

What’s not to love?! If you want more hard baits, make sure to pay for their better boxes though. Still love the basic box though

If I have issue, quick response with not just what I want, but correct result. Love the company