Tires Plus did damage & Bridgestone America omitted/altered inspectors recommendations in denying claims
12-19-2025 We brought our greatly performing car in for a steering fluid leak. 12-20-25 we picked it up with our engine light on and car shaking. We contacted the store immediately and because we were leaving out of town early the next morning, we took video and pictures to show the state of the car upon pick up. Tires Plus said to return the vehicle as soon as we returned. We brought it back and 12-26-25 and they insisted the engine light on and car shaking was unrelated to their work and we could pay for new repairs. We filed a claim with Bridgestone America and after numerous calls, Chad McGhee reached out saying a 3rd party inspector would come. On 1-2-26, an inspection team came and said they suspected the damage was caused by Tires Plus and listed recommendations for a final analysis. 1-6-2026 Chad McGhee of Bridgestone American reached out and denied the claim and told us his findings. His findings did not match the findings that were told to us by the inspection team so we said that we would call him back once we spoke to the inspectors. We reached out to the inspection team and confirmed the report McGhee sent us was only partial and that McGhee had omitted information and as well as the inspection teams' recommendations. The inspectors also noted that Tires Plus did not repair the initial leak hired for ($602 cost). I called Chad McGhee within 30 minutes of his call. I have been leaving multiple calls/emails to Chad McGhee and supervisor of claims Nicholas Griswold and neither have returned any messages. I have been without a running vehicle since 12-19-2025. If Tires Plus had corrected their mistakes, we would not be going through this and I would have an operable car (remember, inspectors also discovered they had not repaired the leak which is what Tires Plus was hired for). I do not recommend having work done at Tires Plus on Seminole Blvd or any shop related to Bridgestone America.






