Good quality -but don't like the logo policy
A number of my friends are in the art/graphic design business and buy books from you on a regular basis, but we are increasingly annoyed by your logo policy. I now notice that Blurb is automatically adding their logo to a front page and a back page and the cost for removing this logo is expensive, particularly when ordering larger books.
Your logo, in addition, is quite large, noticeable and colourful, much more colourful than most publishing companies logos and so adding it to the book detracts and effects the design of the book. While I am more than happy to mention your printing service to design professionals, as my experience with your company has been mostly agreeable to date, it does not seem fair to have it emblazoned so prominently in more than one location on my book (a practice that most mainstream publishers don't do, and if they do it's a black and white, text only version of their name, not bright cyan) particularly since Blurb didn't take part in the design or distribution of the book and my templates are all customised.
Blurb's books are not the least expensive on the market and while the quality is good, it seems wrong that the printer, particularly when I am paying this much per book, should have this kind of design-control on those important pages.
To finish, it seems like sharp practice to then charge for the removal of the logo, and for the cost of this to increase depending on the size of the book (when the logo size/ ink used doesn't not change whether it's a small or large book). If that's your policy, then we, the book designers should be charging Blurb for putting your logo on our books which we pay to print and distribute at our own expense.
My understanding is the book becomes my property when paid for, and since in addition, I am not selling my books through your online service, but distributing them, as I said, at my own expense, having your logo so prominently displayed is not even useful for the purpose of re-ordering. Also, it is misleading because the staff of Blurb had no part in the design and layout of the book, and all templates are customized to my own specifications.
I am having the matter looked into and may be changing printing to another company which is less intrusive. I hope we may come to an amicable arrangement on this issue of which I am sure you've had other complaints. (May I suggest that you might use a sticker with your logo so the purchaser has the option of leaving or removing, particularly for regular customers.)
Question: I design via Booksmart (my own templates, as mentioned), but read that others who use InDesign you add extra pages with your logo, but BookSmart orders you add your logo to existing pages. Why is this? I would like to know if I am ordering a 40 page book through Booksmart app, if the two pages which include your logo are counted, or if I can add two pages (ie 4 pages if you count back to back) at the same cost as a 40 page book? I don't understand why inDesign users would receive extra pages.
5 November 2012
Unprompted review