I was there for longer than one hour and there professional knowledge and excellent approach was evident. They make you feel confortable and take the time to explain how its work the system. You fe... See more

While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
Miss Antonelli and Miss Martini were very helpful, answering my many questions with politeness and high standards of knowledge. Their highly professional skills and kindness made me feel comfortable a... See more
I felt at ease in a very welcoming location. The staff were very kind. Miss Francesca is very knowledgeable and does her job with passion. Thank you for your outstanding professionalism, mastery, and... See more
i experiencia con Autentic ha sido muy buena. Aunque inicialmente realizar este trámite on-line me daba miedo, todo ha ido super bien, han sido muy atentos y muy respetuosos. Me han ido indicando s... See more
Company details
About Auctentic B.V.
Written by the company
Private Advisory House
Diamonds, gemstones, signed jewellery and luxury watches, valued properly
Auctentic is a private advisory house for the valuation and sale of diamonds, gemstones, signed jewellery and luxury watches.
What we help with
A piece that no longer suits the life you live now. A collection being reshaped. Signed jewellery that has come down through a family, or an estate to be divided fairly. The contents of a safe-deposit box left unexamined for years. In every case, the same question: what is this truly worth, and who can answer without an interest of their own.
How we work
Our certified gemologists carry out a full valuation of your piece against international market benchmarks, so its worth is explained rather than asserted. We then position it with more than 2,000 professional buyers worldwide and bring you the strongest offer that competition produces.
Why owners come to us
One valuation, measured against global market data rather than a single buyer's estimate
Access to international demand, so the sale is not limited by what your local market will pay
In-house gemological expertise, so your piece is examined and explained by our own specialists rather than passed to a third party
Complete discretion: no listing, no shop window, no public exposure
An advisory relationship rather than a transaction: we explain each step, answer every question, and move only when you are ready
Our approach
We advise. You decide. There is no obligation at any stage, no pressure to accept, and no deadline on your decision.
Practicalities
Offices in Milan, Paris, Breda and London, by private appointment. A fully remote process is available, with insured collection at our expense through Malca Amit and payment made once the piece has been verified.
We value what you value most.
Contact info
Via Alberico Albricci 9, 20122, Milano, Italy
- 0249751300
- ufficio.italia@auctentic.com
- auctentic.com
Asks customers to review
This company invites their customers to review, whether positive or negative
Replied to 66% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 2 weeks
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Very professional
Very professional, reliable, and attentive. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for jewelry valuations or other related services.
A positive experience characterized by…
A positive experience characterized by availability, professional competence, and, above all, courtesy.
I highly recommended Auctentic
I felt at ease in a very welcoming location. The staff were very kind. Miss Francesca is very knowledgeable and does her job with passion.
Thank you for your outstanding professionalism, mastery, and expertise. I highly recommend Auctentic.
Mi experiencia con Auctentic ha sido…
Español:
Mi experiencia con Auctentic ha sido excelente de principio a fin. Vendí un diamante certificado GIA de 2,80 quilates y todo el proceso fue impecable. Al principio tenía ciertas dudas por tratarse de una joya de gran valor, pero Natalia Romero me explicó cada paso con total transparencia, profesionalidad y amabilidad. Recibí toda la documentación necesaria, las instrucciones de embalaje fueron muy claras y el envío se realizó desde Palma de Mallorca mediante DHL con seguro y seguimiento. Seguí exactamente las indicaciones proporcionadas por Auctentic y en todo momento me sentí segura y acompañada durante el proceso. Lo que más me impresionó fue la rapidez. Desde que entregué el paquete a DHL hasta que el dinero estuvo abonado en mi cuenta bancaria transcurrieron menos de 48 horas. En ese tiempo recibieron el diamante, realizaron la verificación, completaron la valoración y efectuaron la transferencia de manera inmediata. Quiero destacar especialmente la atención de Natalia Romero, siempre disponible, profesional y respondiendo rápidamente a todas mis preguntas. Es difícil encontrar hoy en día una empresa que gestione una operación de este valor con tanta rapidez, transparencia y profesionalidad. Mi experiencia ha superado todas mis expectativas. Recomiendo Auctentic con total confianza a cualquier persona que quiera vender un diamante o una joya de valor. Muchas gracias a Natalia y a todo el equipo por un servicio impecable.
English
My experience with Auctentic was excellent from start to finish. I sold a GIA-certified 2.80-carat diamond and the entire process was flawless. As it was a high-value item, I initially had some concerns, but Natalia Romero explained every step with complete transparency, professionalism and kindness. I received all the necessary documentation, the packing instructions were very clear, and the shipment was arranged from Palma de Mallorca via DHL with insurance and tracking. I followed the instructions exactly as provided and felt safe and informed throughout the entire process. What impressed me the most was the speed. From the moment I handed the package to DHL until the money was credited to my bank account, less than 48 hours had passed. During that time, the diamond was received, verified, evaluated and the payment was transferred immediately. I would especially like to thank Natalia Romero for her professionalism, availability and prompt responses to all my questions. It is rare nowadays to find a company that handles a transaction of this value with such speed, transparency and professionalism. My experience exceeded all expectations. I can confidently recommend Auctentic to anyone looking to sell a valuable diamond or piece of jewellery. Many thanks to Natalia and the entire Auctentic team for an outstanding service.
Trustable option …
I was there for longer than one hour and there professional knowledge and excellent approach was evident. They make you feel confortable and take the time to explain how its work the system.
You feel no pressure in taking decisions that you may regret later. Short a good and learning experience.
The service was excellent
The service was excellent, with expert knowledge of diamonds, and guided me through the whole process so I could understand every aspect. Highly recommend!
Trust
All went fine, quickly and exactly, as agreed. Preliminary price indication was met so no unwanted surprises. Serious business partner.
Excellent service
Excellent service! I am very satisfied with the help I received. Mr. Solomon assisted me very well and was professional, friendly, and very helpful. I highly recommend doing business with him.
Good experience with this company
I had a good experience with this company. The whole process was smooth, quick, and very professional
Ik was really happy with the service….
Ik was really happy with the service….
Horrible Experience, Horrible Customer Service, False Advertising
If you're looking to sell a diamond, I WOULD RECOMMEND TO STAY AWAY from this company.
In theory, their entire appraisal and quote process sounds good, but in reality it's the worst experience I had in 10 years when it comes to the luxury industry.
I submitted the pics, the GIA certificate of my diamond, all the specs, all the contact details, and waited. And waited, and waited even more.
After almost two weeks I sent them a follow up via email, asking if there was an issue with my request, and I got no reply for them.
Then after 5 more days, I got an email saying that they saw that my phone number is from outside of the European Union, and they can't work with that.
My phone number is from Romania, which is been part of the EU since 2007.
After I replied to that email, they replied after 4 days saying "yes we know Romania is part of EU, but we only accept quotes from Italy, France and Spain" all these while they claim they accept diamonds from the entire European Union.
The reply came signed by their office manager, so it wasn't just some automated reply bot.
This company is using false advertising for their entire purchase system, and the customer service is POOR and almost non-existent.
I've been selling high-end items, watches, and diamonds for more than 10 years, but I never encountered such an amateur level of doing trade, and business.
I would recommend you AVOIDING this company if you don't want to waste your time.

Reply from Auctentic B.V.
High professional standards
Miss Antonelli and Miss Martini were very helpful, answering my many questions with politeness and high standards of knowledge. Their highly professional skills and kindness made me feel comfortable and safe. Their advice was always clear and deeply explained. Thank you for your assistance and support.
STUPID OFFERS
Totally out of the market with ridiculous offers. When they have to sell, they start from the Rapaport price, when they have to buy, they offer 70/80% of the Rapaport price... Poor thing who ends up with them. Not even close.

Reply from Auctentic B.V.
Very friendly and reliable.
Very friendly and reliable.
Payment was received within 3 hours and I had no problems whatsoever.
I had a wonderful experience with them
Great deal and wonderful service
It was great pleasure to work with your company. Everything was professional and polite. Special thanks to Margherita's professionalism
Thank you for wonderful service and the best deal
Mr David Gerbi
Mr. Davide Gerbi is a very professional man, kind and Competent
I think AUCTENTIC is the good gemstone…
I think AUCTENTIC is the good gemstone buy & sell website. very user friendly and useful. excellent Experian's with them
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.